Recruitment is the gateway to every organisation’s talent and culture. But in today’s regulatory landscape, it’s not enough to simply find the right candidate; you must do so within a framework of strict compliance. This is becoming more complex than ever, especially as organisations increasingly rely on contractors and freelancers. Navigating this landscape requires not only adherence to traditional safeguards, but also a thorough understanding and application of contractor-specific rules.
Why Is Recruitment Compliance So Important?
- Legal Protection and Avoiding Penalties: Recruitment compliance ensures your hiring process adheres to all relevant laws and regulations, protecting your business from costly lawsuits, fines, and reputational damage. Non-compliance can result in penalties exceeding hundreds of thousands of pounds, not to mention the long-term impact on your brand.
- Fairness and Equal Opportunity: Compliance guarantees that every candidate is treated fairly, regardless of age, gender, race, religion, disability, or other protected characteristics. This is not just a legal requirement under the UK’s Equality Act 2010 or the US’s EEOC guidelines, but a cornerstone of assembling a diverse and inclusive workforce with relevant and complementary skills.
- Data Protection: General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the Data Protection Act 2018 (DPA 2018) mean that all organisations must handle candidate and staff data responsibly. Mishandling personal data can lead to severe fines and loss of trust. GDPR, DPA 2018, case law and the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) all apply to your organisation.
- Right to Work and Immigration Checks: In the UK, the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006 requires employers to verify that every new hire is legally eligible to work. Non-compliance can result in criminal charges and business disruption.
- Consistency and Transparency: Standardised, compliant processes ensure all candidates are assessed on the same criteria, reducing risk of bias and making recruitment decisions defensible and auditable.
For organisations hiring contractors or freelance workers there are further compliance challenges:
- IR35 (Off-Payroll Working Rules): IR35 remains the cornerstone of contractor compliance in the UK. It determines whether a contractor should be taxed as an employee or as a self-employed individual. Since 2021, medium and large businesses (and public sector bodies) are responsible for assessing each contractor’s IR35 status and issuing a Status Determination Statement (SDS).
- National Minimum Wage and National Insurance Contributions (NICs): As of April 2025, minimum wage rates have increased, and the NIC threshold has been lowered, with the employer’s rate rising from 13.8% to 15%. These changes impact payroll costs for contractors engaged via agencies or umbrella companies.
- Umbrella Company Regulation: New legislation is making agencies responsible for PAYE on payments to workers supplied through umbrella companies, increasing the need for diligence and compliance in these arrangements.
- Documentation Checks: Contractors must provide comprehensive documentation, including evidence of business operations, insurance, and eligibility to work in the UK. Employers must maintain thorough records to demonstrate compliance and support IR35 determinations
The Role of Process Management Tools
Modern process management and compliance tools like Maly’s Okuda platform are invaluable in navigating complex regulations:
Automated Compliance Checks: Digital platforms like Okuda, are designed to be configured to automate checks like right-to-work verifications, IR35 status assessments, and documentation collection, reducing manual errors and ensuring up-to-date compliance.
Centralised Record-Keeping: Process management systems store all relevant contracts, SDS statements, and audit trails in one place, making it easy to demonstrate compliance during audits or disputes.
Real-Time Updates: Tools like Okuda can be quickly updated to reflect the latest regulatory changes, ensuring your processes remain compliant as laws evolve.
Workflow Standardisation: By embedding compliant workflows, process management tools ensure every contractor engagement follows the same rigorous checks, from onboarding to offboarding.
Flexible and Secure Repository: Extend your workflow beyond initial search, sift and selection processes into a system of record for appraisals, annual reviews, disciplinary procedures. Record all options considered, decisions made, and actions taken. Alongside or, better still, integrated with payroll systems.
Benefits of Compliance
So what are the benefits of having standard recruitment processes and of using process control tools like Okuda to ensure compliance at every step?
- Reduces Risk of Discrimination: Standardised processes, such as structured interviews and consistent selection criteria, help ensure that every candidate is assessed fairly and objectively, reducing the consequences of unconscious bias or the risk of discrimination claims.
- Ensures Legal Defensibility: Documenting every stage of recruitment, from job adverts, job description, interview notes, selection decisions, and job offers made, provides a clear audit trail if your decisions are ever challenged.
- Builds Employer Brand: A transparent, fair, and compliant recruitment process enhances your reputation, making it easier to attract top talent and build trust with candidates, clients, and partners.
- Supports Business Agility: By clearly defining contractor status and responsibilities, organisations can engage talent flexibly while remaining within legal boundaries.
- Improves Business Performance: Compliance isn’t just about avoiding risk; it’s about building a stronger, more diverse, and more innovative workforce, which is proven to drive better business outcomes.
- Improves Business Resilience: A capacity to recall facts easily, with precision and accuracy, essential at all times but especially when your organisation is required to respond to Subject Access Requests (SARs) within deadline without requiring an extension, or when your organisation has to brief its own legal representatives.
To find out more about how Okuda can help you recruit in a compliant way and unlock all of these benefits please contact Maly today to start a conversation. In part 2 of this article we will explore how the adoption of AI into the end-to-end recruitment process presents new challenges to compliant hiring and explore ways this can be mitigated.
~
Researched and written by Mary Chisholm and Matt Lawson, July 2025.
References are as per hyperlinks above and provided in good faith. We cannot accept responsibility for the content on external websites.
This article is also available online at https://maly.co.uk/the-critical-importance-of-compliance-in-recruitment-part-1/
Thank you for reading.
~